This is the respective issue for https://www.drupal.org/project/drupal/issues/742344, a blocker for the #5346 backport, and related to #1040.
Problem/Motivation
Accessibility guidelines recommend specific, meaningful error messages when required form elements are empty. However, FAPI currently does not support custom error messages for required elements.
Proposed resolution
Support a
#required_errorproperty for form elements. If set, this message will be used when a required form element is empty, instead of the default "Field x is required." Additionally set a#required_but_emptyflag automatically during validation when the required field is empty. This is an internal property and is not set manually. It allows#element_validatehandlers to set a custom required error message, but without having to re-implement the complex logic to figure out whether the field value is empty.Remaining tasks
Commit feature and document these properties. The feature is a small API improvement that is applicable to both D8 and D7.
User interface changes
None.
API changes
Minor, backwards-compatible addition only. No existing code will be affected. Addition of two FAPI element properties:
#required_error#required_but_empty
Advocate for this issue: @klonos
Recent comments
Worth mentioning as it was in zulip chat by @yorkshirepudding I just tested and the two work together without issue as long as you don't use the "Exclude comments from Content...
Search does not include comments
There is also Node Comments Search - this searches the node and all comments (default search is node and first page of comments) as part of the content search. Izzy's module above is a separate...
Search does not include comments
I have created a new module comment_search
Search does not include comments