Here's what the settings for this formatter look like in Backdrop:

...and here are the available options for the "Display" setting:

...and here's the summary of the settings:

This seems very limiting, since: - The option is called "time ago", but it also allows setting it to a "time hence" - it would be better called something like "time difference" instead - You can only set the formatter to "time ago" or "time hence", which works fine if you know for sure that the field will be used to enter dates either in the past or in the future, but not both. So if you set a date in the future, the time diff will be shown as "time hence" ...but once that date comes and passes and is in the past, it will not work.
In D8+, you are allowed to set a format for both ago/hence:
...and the summary indicates that things will work for both future/past dates:

Recent comments
The inability to check for and install updates makes website development and maintenance extremely difficult. Managing over ten websites across two different hosting providers—one of which is...
Unable to run update - fails with Connection timed out
Thanks for the response, Herb! Since I posted that I did some more testing and have posted this issue https://github.com/backdrop-contrib/tfa_basic/issues/33 In fact, if both email...
TFA - how to setup fallback options 'per user'
I'll test this tomorrow to see if I can replicate the problem and report back. It's not "per user" so it should be working.
TFA - how to setup fallback options 'per user'