Screenshot says it all:

Either these options act as OR or AND, it's silly. The second time that the user tried to re-add the "front page" condition, that option should not have been available.
Making this issue a generic one and not specifically for the front page case, because there might be other cases too.
GitHub Issue #:
1021
Recent comments
Worth mentioning as it was in zulip chat by @yorkshirepudding I just tested and the two work together without issue as long as you don't use the "Exclude comments from Content...
Search does not include comments
There is also Node Comments Search - this searches the node and all comments (default search is node and first page of comments) as part of the content search. Izzy's module above is a separate...
Search does not include comments
I have created a new module comment_search
Search does not include comments